A.J. is a photographer for the school newspaper. Valentine's day is coming, and with it comes the reminder to A.J. that she doesn't have a boyfriend and she doesn't have a cover photo for the Valentine's edition of the paper. Then, one night, driving home she finds a cupid in the road and takes it home. This is no ordinary cupid. His name is Jonathan, and he can shoot an arrow into the person of your desire and make them fall head over heels in love with you. A.J. has Jonathan shoot an arrow into the guy she has a major crush on, and that young man, Peter Terris, absolutely loses his heart and apparently his mind. A.J. has more devotion than she ever could have dreamed of, and it isn't all it's cracked up to be.